Good guys wear red! DD and the Punisher hunt down Hogman for selling drugs to kids, but the two heroes clash over their methods; DD ends up shooting the Punisher with his own gun.
Good Guys Wear Red The story arc of Daredevil #184 (published in 1982) is a pivotal moment in Frank Miller’s celebrated run on the series, titled "Good Guys Wear Red!". This issue brings Daredevil into a moral and ideological conflict with another Marvel vigilante: The Punisher. Here's a detailed breakdown of the story:
Plot Overview
The issue explores the clash between Daredevil's moral code and The Punisher's extreme approach to justice, as they both confront the corruption and crime that plague Hell's Kitchen.
The Crime and Investigation:
Daredevil begins investigating the tragic shooting of a high school student, linked to a drug-dealing operation.
The murder highlights the devastating impact of drugs and organized crime on the community, a recurring theme in Miller’s run.
The Punisher Enters the Picture:
Daredevil crosses paths with The Punisher, who is also targeting the drug ring. However, The Punisher’s methods—using lethal force—conflict with Daredevil’s commitment to justice within the law.
The Punisher justifies his violent actions as necessary to eradicate evil, while Daredevil argues that such extremism undermines the principles of justice.
Clash of Ideologies:
The core of the issue is the physical and ideological battle between Daredevil and The Punisher.
Their confrontation is intense and highlights their differing views on how to handle crime:
Daredevil believes in protecting life and ensuring that justice is served in the courtroom, even if it’s flawed.
The Punisher sees the legal system as ineffective and believes criminals deserve immediate, lethal punishment.
Showdown and Aftermath:
The issue culminates in a brutal fight between the two vigilantes. Daredevil ultimately stops The Punisher from executing one of the drug dealers, emphasizing his stance that no one has the right to play judge, jury, and executioner.
Despite their clash, both characters share a grudging respect for one another’s commitment to justice, even if they vehemently disagree on how it’s achieved.
Themes
Moral Ambiguity: The issue explores whether the ends justify the means when combating crime, with Daredevil and The Punisher representing two extremes of this debate.
Justice vs. Vengeance: Daredevil embodies justice through law, while The Punisher represents unrestrained vengeance.
Corruption and Urban Decay: The story reflects the social issues of the time, such as the rise of drug-related violence and systemic corruption.
Art and Tone
Frank Miller’s dark, gritty storytelling is perfectly matched by Klaus Janson’s heavy inks and shadowy, noir-inspired artwork. The atmosphere underscores the bleakness of the environment and the moral complexity of the story.
Significance
Daredevil #184 is a landmark issue in Miller’s run, as it pits Daredevil against one of Marvel’s most morally divisive characters. It not only deepens Daredevil’s character but also sets the tone for future stories involving moral and ethical conflicts.
If you’re interested in how this issue fits into Daredevil’s broader storyline or The Punisher’s development as a character, feel free to ask!