Teslatroy

all messages by user

9/26/2021
Topic:
Highest possible grade with detached cover...

Teslatroy
Teslatroy
The cover/back has slipped through the staples of my Avengers 59. The cover is clean, crisp, sharp corners bright colors no creases and the back is white with no stains. the inside is white to yellowish white. no defects... the staples are silver, no rusting... im just curious what the highest such a book could get with grading through cgc... if the only defect is that the cover has torn off the staples. also should note the tears at the staple holes do not extend, they are tight and only where the staple was. I did look this up, ive seen people say the max was 4.5, then others show evidence of 9+'s with detached covers... then others say 2.5 is the max... Does anyone have real experience or knowledge with what to expect? i plan to grade the book and I'll update later with the result. also will add pics in a few days im currently traveling.

Thanks, Im new here so happy to join!
Troy
1